Contents
An employee rewards program works when people earn points for clear reasons, spend them on things they actually chose, and receive them quickly. It’s worth getting right: in Gallup research with Workhuman, well-recognized employees were 45% less likely to have left their jobs two years later. The setup decides whether you get that result or a catalog nobody opens.
Most programs that stall don’t fail on intent. They fail on the boring parts. Points get issued but the catalog is thin. The catalog is good but nobody’s sizes are in stock. Or someone in HR ends up packing boxes on Thursday afternoons, and the program quietly shrinks to whatever that person has time for.
So here’s the setup, in the order the decisions actually need making.
How to set up an employee rewards program
- Decide what earns points. Keep it to a short list people can repeat: work anniversaries, birthdays, manager and peer recognition, and anything specific to your business, like safety milestones or customer reviews.
- Set a points budget per person per year. Work it out from your headcount and how often each trigger happens, so the cost is known before launch.
- Build a short catalog. Eight well-chosen products usually beat forty. Cover a range of point values, and carry apparel in a full size range.
- Automate the predictable triggers. Anniversaries and birthdays shouldn’t depend on a manager remembering.
- Decide who fulfils the orders. Someone has to hold the stock, pack it and ship it, to offices and to home addresses.
- Launch with points already in people’s accounts. The first visit should be spending, not browsing.
Steps 4 and 5 are the ones most programs underestimate. Platforms make issuing points easy. But getting a hoodie in the right size to a nurse on nights in another city is a different job.
Let people choose their own reward
Choice beats curation. When someone else picks the gift, it’s usually wrong for a good share of the people who get it: wrong size, wrong color, something they already own. A points catalog solves that by letting each person pick.
That’s the idea behind a company swag store with points redemption. You approve the catalog once, people redeem points for what they want, and the stock sits in a warehouse rather than under someone’s desk. Because you pay for what gets redeemed, there’s no platform fee eating into the rewards budget.
What belongs in it depends on your workforce, but a solid starting catalog looks something like this:
- Apparel people wear outside work: a quality hoodie, a quarter-zip, a jacket, a cap
- Drinkware and a good bag
- A few premium-brand pieces at the top of the points range
- Something practical at the low end, so a single recognition can buy something real
Points, gift cards and taxes
Gift cards are simple to issue, but they’re taxable wages. IRS Publication 15-B says cash and cash equivalents, gift cards included, are never excludable as a small fringe benefit, no matter how little they’re worth.
Merchandise can be treated differently in one specific case. IRS Publication 15-B lets employers exclude employee achievement awards from wages when they’re tangible property given for length of service or safety achievement, presented meaningfully, and not disguised pay. The limit is $400 per employee per year, or $1,600 under a written, qualified awards plan.
The detail that matters for rewards programs: the exclusion doesn’t cover gift cards, but it does cover letting the employee choose from a limited assortment of items you’ve preselected. In other words, a service-award catalog can qualify where a gift card can’t.
Points earned for other reasons, like peer recognition or hitting a sales target, generally don’t fit that exclusion. How your program should be treated depends on what triggers each award, so walk it through with whoever runs payroll before launch.
Automate the dates with your HRIS
Anniversaries and birthdays are the backbone of most programs because they’re predictable. They’re also the first thing to slip when they depend on a manager remembering.
Connecting the program to your HRIS fixes that. Hire dates and birthdays come from the system, points land on the right day, and nobody keeps a spreadsheet. We work with ADP, Workday, UKG, BambooHR, Rippling, Gusto, Paycor, Justworks, Namely, Eddy, SurePayroll and QuickBooks Payroll.
Rewards programs in healthcare, hospitality and construction
The same setup bends differently by industry. Three examples show how.
Healthcare
Staff are spread across locations and shifts, and many never sit at a desk. Ship rewards to home addresses, so a night-shift nurse isn’t waiting for a box at a front desk that’s closed when they arrive. For healthcare organizations with several locations, one catalog with per-location budgets keeps things fair without central ordering.
Hospitality
Turnover is the constraint. If points take a year to add up to anything, most frontline staff won’t be around to spend them. Shorter earning cycles and low-point items that can be redeemed in the first few months matter more here. Restaurant and hotel groups running per-property hospitality programs usually let each location manage its own recognition within one approved catalog.
Construction
Safety milestones are the most common trigger, and they’re also the easiest to get wrong. Reward safe behavior people can see, like training completed and near-misses reported. OSHA’s 2018 guidance points to programs that reward reporting hazards, and warns against any program used to penalize someone for reporting an injury. Crews skew to larger sizes, so the catalog needs the full range. Our construction recognition programs hold that stock so awards ship the week they’re earned.
How to tell if it’s working
Four numbers tell you most of what you need. Redemption rate (are points being spent?). Time from earning to delivery. Adoption in the first two weeks after launch, which is a strong early sign of whether a store gets used at all. And, over time, retention among people who’ve been recognized versus people who haven’t.
If redemption is low, the catalog is usually the problem, not the people. Swap the slow items out.
A rewards program is never finished, and that’s fine. If you’d like help setting up the catalog, the points and the fulfilment so it runs without anyone in HR packing boxes, request a demo and we’ll build a proposed program around your team.
