Contents
The best law firm holiday gifts start with the list, not the catalog. Most clients can accept a modest, well-made gift, but some recipients can’t: a federal employee can generally take gifts worth only $20 per occasion and $50 a year from one source, judges should get a card at most, and referral sources fall under the rules on paying for referrals. Sort the list first, then pick the gifts.
It sounds obvious. It rarely happens that way. The list usually comes from three places (the partners’ own contacts, the CRM, last year’s spreadsheet), gets merged in November, and goes out with one gift for everyone on it.
And most of the time that’s fine. But the handful of names that shouldn’t be on a standard list are exactly the ones that can turn a thank-you into an awkward phone call.
Sort your holiday list before you choose gifts
Split the list into groups before anyone looks at products. Each group gets a different gift, or none at all.
- Clients and their in-house teams. The main list. A good gift, sent to the right address.
- Government and public sector clients. Strict dollar caps, often lower than people expect.
- Referral sources. Other lawyers, accountants, financial advisers. Nominal thank-yous only.
- Judges and court staff. A card, not a gift.
- The people who make the relationship work. Clients’ assistants, paralegals, legal ops. Often forgotten, and often the ones who remember.
Clients’ own employers may cap what their people can accept too, which our law firm client gift programs are built around. If a general counsel’s company has a gift policy, a modest piece that lands well beats an expensive one that has to be sent back.
Government clients and the $20 rule
Federal employees can generally accept unsolicited gifts worth $20 or less per source per occasion, with a cap of $50 a year from any one source. That’s the de minimis exception in the federal ethics rules, 5 CFR 2635.204. It doesn’t cover cash.
Two details catch firms out. First, the “source” is the firm, not the individual partner, because the rule treats a company and its employees as one person. So three partners each sending something small to the same agency lawyer are adding up to one total. Second, the employee can’t pay the difference to keep a gift that’s over the limit.
State and local government employees have their own rules, and they vary by state and by agency. If a client sits in a public agency, a card or a $20-and-under item is the safe default until their ethics office says otherwise.
Referral sources and nominal thank-you gifts
A thank-you gift for a referral is allowed under the ABA model rules, and in the states that follow them, if it’s nominal and not payment for the referral. The ABA added that exception to its model rules in 2018. Washington, for example, adopted it in 2021, and a 2025 Washington State Bar News column describes a dinner or a bottle of wine as the kind of thing that would likely qualify. An all-expense-paid trip wouldn’t.
So which version applies to your firm? It depends on your state, because not every state adopted the change in the same form. The model rule’s two conditions are worth following either way. The gift can’t be tied to any promise or understanding about future referrals, and it has to look like appreciation rather than a fee. A holiday gift that goes to every referral source, at the same modest level, fits that pattern far better than a bigger gift to whoever sent the most work.
Judges and court staff get a card
Leave judges and court staff off the gift list. Judicial conduct codes bar a judge from accepting anything that would appear to undermine their impartiality, and gifts from a lawyer likely to appear before the judge are appropriate “only in the rarest of circumstances,” in the words of the comment to Indiana’s Rule 3.13, which follows the ABA model.
Greeting cards are fine. They’re specifically listed among the things a judge can accept. Send a card.
What to send clients this year
For the main list, tier it by relationship rather than sending one gift to everyone. Three tiers is usually enough.
| Tier | Who | What tends to work |
|---|---|---|
| Key relationships | General counsel and decision makers at your largest clients | A desk piece personalized with their initials rather than the firm’s name |
| Core clients | Everyone else you’ve worked with this year | A quality, quietly branded item from one approved range |
| Teams | A client’s legal department or your contacts’ assistants | One shareable gift for the office, so nobody is left out |
| Referral sources | Lawyers, accountants, advisers who sent work | The same modest item for everyone in the group |
| Public sector and judges | Agency lawyers, court staff | A card, or an item under the recipient’s limit |
The team gift is the one most firms skip. A client’s paralegals and assistants often deal with your firm day to day, and one gift for the whole office is easy to get right.
When law firm holiday gifts should land
Earlier is better. By mid-December, a general counsel’s office is full of gift boxes and cards from every firm and vendor they use, and yours is one of many. A gift that arrives the week after Thanksgiving gets noticed. One sent for the New Year, with a note about the year ahead, sidesteps the pile entirely.
Work backward from that date. Personalized items take longer than stock items, and the slowest part is usually the address list, not the gift. In-house lawyers aren’t always in the office, so confirm whether each gift goes to the office or the house before anything ships.
This is the part of holiday gifting we take off a firm’s plate: we hold the stock, handle personalization and the address list, and ship direct inside the window you choose.
Planning next year’s list now
Once this year’s gifts are out, write down what went to whom. Next November, the list starts from a record instead of three spreadsheets, and the government contacts, referral sources and judges are already flagged.
It’s also worth keeping the approved pieces available after the holidays. Referral thank-yous and closing gifts come up all year, and a company store any partner can order from means each one goes out at the same level without someone starting the search again.
That small step does more for next year than any gift choice.
If you’d like help building the tiers, sourcing the pieces and getting them out on time, talk to our team and we’ll put a holiday program together around your list.
